Sunday, June 7, 2020


Moab, UT

59.4 F

    Expert: County’s current voting districts violate doctrines of one person, one vote

    Featured Stories

    Ignoring own standards and experts, Utah commission pushes reopening

    The COVID-19 model from the CDC predicts an increase in deaths from the coronavirus from Utah in the coming weeks, and key indicators predict more hospitalizations are to come.

    Leaving Guatemala

    I selected “send me where I’m needed most,” my desire to immerse myself in another country’s culture not affixed to any location in particular.

    Widespread testing is key to Moab’s path forward

    Once a person develops symptoms of COVID-19, it has likely already been days since they started unknowingly spreading the virus. As such, local health officials want to expand testing locally for the coronavirus.

    County to diversify post-virus

    The impacts of the pandemic have renewed local leaders’ focus on a topic many have worried over for years but must now confront in much starker terms: Economic diversification.

    Arches, Canyonlands to reopen May 29

    Arches and Canyonlands national parks will partially reopen to the public at the end of the month, according to a spokesperson for the parks, following guidance from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and state and local public health authorities.

    The party is over at Imagination Station art supply store

    Cindy Sue Hunter serves a customer at her art supply store, Imagination Station, which has been reconfigured to allow shoppers to do what Hunter calls “door shopping."
    Doug McMurdo
    Doug McMurdo
    Editor Doug McMurdo reports on news out of the Moab City Center, tourism, courts, change of government and more.

    Software makes drawing maps easy as slicing pie

    The seven members of the Grand County Change of Form of Government Study Committee might not be on the same page when it comes to election districts – some want candidates to run at-large, most want a combination of representatives from districts and at-large – but drawing district maps will be almost a cinch.

    That’s the message election district map expert William Cooper shared with the committee at Friday’s meeting. That isn’t to suggest there aren’t serious issues to overcome.

    Cooper in a teleconference said he looks at basic U.S. Census Bureau data and current district maps before he does anything else in order to determine how he would, if ultimately retained, draw draft boundaries. “It varies from plan to plan,” said the out-of-town consultant.

    He uses census blocks, which he defined as the smallest geographic unit used by the Census Bureau for tabulation of 100 percent of the data collected from all houses, rather than a sample of houses. He uses computer software called Maptitude, which is designed for redistricting.

    There are a couple of problems. One is the age of the information that would be used. “We have very old information,” he said before estimating Grand County has grown by 500 residents since the 2010 Census, which is what he or any other map expert would use. The 2020 Census results will not be available until winter and spring of 2021, well past the deadline for the committee to create a new form of government.

    He estimates most of the growth over the past decade has occurred within the Moab city limits, but he also said dated census information can be off by 20 percent or more.

    The overriding objective of drawing voting district maps is to protect the constitutional doctrine of one person, one vote. In Grand County, that means drawing districts with about 1,845 people each, which is a far cry from what’s happening. He said the five districts in Grand County – which mirror those for the Grand County School District – are either over- or under-populated.

    District 2 is under-populated by 35 percent, districts 3-5 are over-populated by 15 percent, and District 1 is “just about perfect.” With this in mind, it is virtually impossible the current districts would remain intact should the study committee ultimately decide to have them. Population is the only element used to create a district, taking neighborhoods into consideration as well as city and town boundaries.

    Cooper said the committee could stick with five districts, or have three districts with other candidates running at-large. That would put about 3,000 people in each district, with the City of Moab being home to most of the people in two of the districts and the third almost exclusively rural. No matter how it shakes out, the number of citizens in each district cannot vary by more than five percent or the districts will be out of compliance with the one person, one vote mandate.

    Cooper, who worked with the Navajo Nation in its successful fight to change longtime gerrymandering in San Juan County, reminded study committee members there are only two metrics courts will look at to determine if a district is valid or not: that it complies with the Voting Rights Act and, again, falls in line with one person, one vote.

    The study committee could eventually retain Cooper’s expertise should it decide the new form of government will have candidates who run by district, either entirely or in combination with candidates who would run at-large, which is what’s in play with the current form of government, with five council members running in a district and two at-large.

    Thanks to Maptitude, Cooper could conceivably draw up maps in a matter of minutes – once and if the study committee agrees on a plan.

    Share this!

    - Advertisement -

    Latest News

    Police chief chases man behaving badly

    File photo by Carter Pape A Moab man with a history of drug...

    CFI modifies summer camp due to pandemic; won’t do overnight programs

    Canyonlands Field Institute has made the difficult decision to cancel its traditional overnight camps this summer, but is continuing to hold a new type of day camp.

    Economic injury loans in Utah reach $365.3M

    The U.S. Small Business Administration said in a statement that as of May 25, the Economic Injury Disaster Loan Program approved 500,074 loans nationally totaling $42.4 billion.

    Synergy donates $40K to local nonprofits

    Thatcher Vagts, president of The Synergy Company, distributes coronavirus relief checks to nonprofits. Courtesy photo The Synergy Company...

    Hwy. 191 work continues with paving, storm drain

    An excavator operator works on Highway 191 as part of a project by the Utah Department of Transportation to expand the...