Monday, July 6, 2020


Moab, UT

94.2 F

    Tie vote dooms OSTA cell tower plan

    Featured Stories

    At 99, Moab man is knighted by France

    “The French people will never forget his courage and devotion to the great cause of freedom,”

    Leaving Guatemala, Part 4: ‘A year in the land of eternal spring’

    Though I planned to return someday, whether as a Peace Corps volunteer or not, this experience proved that even the best-laid plans go awry.

    Leaving Guatemala, Part 3: Sudden departure came with painful goodbyes

    Men donned wooden masks and numerous layers of sweatshirts and ponchos then proceeded to hit each other with whips as they danced around the town square.

    Leaving Guatemala Part 2: There wasn’t enough time to say goodbye

    To say I woke up on the Monday morning of the evacuation...

    Ignoring own standards and experts, Utah commission pushes reopening

    The COVID-19 model from the CDC predicts an increase in deaths from the coronavirus from Utah in the coming weeks, and key indicators predict more hospitalizations are to come.
    Doug McMurdo
    Doug McMurdo
    Editor Doug McMurdo reports on news out of the Moab City Center, tourism, courts, change of government and more.
    Tierney Rowe, left, of InSite Towers 2, LLC, makes her pitch to build a 130-foot cell tower on Old Spanish Trail Arena property to the Grand County Council earlier this month. To Rowe’s left is OSTA Director Steve Swift. Photo by Doug McMurdo

    A tie vote doomed plans to build a 130-foot cell tower on the grounds of Old Spanish Trail Arena when the Grand County Council met earlier this month, based in large part on a perception the proposed Option and Ground Lease Agreement between the county and InSite Towers Development 2, LLC did not offer enough revenue to the county, as well as “pushback” from nearby residents opposed to the plan.

    Grand County Attorney Christina Sloan after months of negotiations recommended the council deny the request.

    Vice Chair Terry Morse and Member Mary McGann both voiced concerns regarding the rent InSite Towers would pay – roughly $1,250 a month plus $400 for up to four customers that use the tower. Morse said it was “out of kilter.” He said towers such as what the company proposed “make a lot of money. I thought the percentage would be much better for the county.”

    Morse also said council members received “a lot of pushback from people who don’t want a 130-foot-tall cell tower” in the neighborhood. There were a number of concerns raised in letters sent to the county, with some worried that any future access from Spanish Valley Drive to Highway 191 would be blocked by the tower. Issues such as lighting and how or if the tower would impact the county’s dark skies ordinance was another concern. Morse said he had nothing against the company, and conceded that improved communications would be welcome, but he suggested a better location could be found.

    Sloan said the tower would have to comply with the county’s dark skies rules and she cautioned that the county could not use the land anywhere within the 130-foot “fall zone” for the duration of the 40-year term of the lease – which was another point of contention for some council members.

    Sloan also said it “doesn’t make sense to tie up a very valuable county property,” for that length of time.

    OSTA Director Steve Swift said in backup materials that he first met with InSite Towers in February 2018 to negotiate a deal with the potential of bringing in more revenue. But after a year of “extensive” negotiations with the Grand County District Attorney – including the last eight months since Sloan took office – Sloan advised him to recommend the county reject the agreement due to the two sides’ failure to agree on the three issues raised.

    Member Jaylyn Hawks said the 40-year lease was “a really long time,” but InSite Towers representative Tierney Rowe said the “boilerplate” term for such leases is typically 55 years, reasoning the company would have to pay a higher rental rate under a short-term lease. She also said it is difficult to find customers if the underlying lease on a tower is not for the long term, so they’re “going into it with eyes wide open.”

    Regarding payments, she said the county would receive “almost half” of the lease revenue. Rowe also said she didn’t “understand the concern over space,” saying the design portion of the project would specify county design standards, such as light shrouding, to remain in compliance with the county’s dark skies regulations.

    She added, however, that it’s up to the FAA to determine whether the tower needs to be lighted. The company, she said, would also allow EMS equipment on the tower at no charge, but that wasn’t a valuable bargaining chip. It was noted that EMS and law enforcement communications “need help” in the north area of the county, along the river corridor, so the offer at the arena “wouldn’t help communications.”

    Chair Evan Clapper, Morse and McGann voted in opposition, which resulted in a tie vote and a rejection of the lease. Member Curtis Wells was not in attendance.

    Share this!

    - Advertisement -

    Latest News

    GOP’s Cox, Reyes move on to General Election

    If the figures hold, Cox will face off against University of Utah law professor Christopher Peterson, a Democrat, and Libertarian Daniel Cottam, a surgeon, in November’s general election.

    Man pleads guilty to double manslaughter

    He faces up to 15 years apiece for the deaths of Vilsar Camey, 45, and Camey’s 10-year-old son, Israel on Feb. 9.

    Eklecticafe was cramped but quaint. Then the virus hit

    “It’s so sad to say that, even though there’s a relief for me, but the COVID thing… I just couldn’t sustainably reopen."

    500K facemasks headed to Utah students, teachers

    The state procured the masks from H.M. Cole and Totopazi and will be distributed to school districts in the “greatest need."

    After three years and a tripled budget, Seekhaven has new director

    My main goal is to stabilize our current programming and fortify our working relationships with the first responders in our community.