Monday, July 6, 2020


Moab, UT

94.2 F

    Ignoring own standards and experts, Utah commission pushes reopening

    CDC model predicts increase in Utah deaths; key indicators predict more hospitalizations to come

    Featured Stories

    At 99, Moab man is knighted by France

    “The French people will never forget his courage and devotion to the great cause of freedom,”

    Leaving Guatemala, Part 4: ‘A year in the land of eternal spring’

    Though I planned to return someday, whether as a Peace Corps volunteer or not, this experience proved that even the best-laid plans go awry.

    Leaving Guatemala, Part 3: Sudden departure came with painful goodbyes

    Men donned wooden masks and numerous layers of sweatshirts and ponchos then proceeded to hit each other with whips as they danced around the town square.

    Leaving Guatemala Part 2: There wasn’t enough time to say goodbye

    To say I woke up on the Monday morning of the evacuation...

    Ignoring own standards and experts, Utah commission pushes reopening

    The COVID-19 model from the CDC predicts an increase in deaths from the coronavirus from Utah in the coming weeks, and key indicators predict more hospitalizations are to come.
    Carter Pape
    Carter Pape
    Reporter Carter Pape covers news out of the Grand County Council Chambers, including housing, tourism, crime, and more.
    Moab businesses have begun reopening as Utah lifts restrictions promoting public health amid the COVID-19 pandemic. A state commission tasked with providing Gov. Gary Herbert recommendations on the state’s next steps responding to the pandemic voted unanimously Tuesday to move much of the state to green despite key indicators and experts signaling against it. Photo by Carter Pape

    The Utah commission providing recommendations to Gov. Gary Herbert regarding the state’s response to the pandemic has three key indicators it is following to check for whether the state is at a “adequate level of stability” to warrant moving to lower-risk phases. Two of those indicators show Utah is not at that point, and the state’s epidemiologist said Wednesday, June 3 that she recommends no jurisdiction in Utah move to the lowest risk phase at this time.

    “We in public health look at our public health data and make recommendations for restrictions or loosening restrictions to the governor and the commission, and based on the data we have seen in the past week, we don’t recommend any jurisdiction in the state going to green,” said Dr. Angela Dunn, the state epidemiologist, at a Wednesday press conference.

    Tune in to today's COVID-19 briefing with Dr. Angela Dunn.

    Posted by Governor Gary Herbert on Wednesday, June 3, 2020
    At time mark 7:20 during the above press conference, recorded Wednesday, June 3, State Epidemiologist Angela Dunn answers a question about the commission’s proposal to move much of Utah to the green risk phase.

    Despite these warnings, the Public Health and Economic Emergency Commission unanimously voted Tuesday, June 2 to recommend allowing much of the state to move from the “low risk” phase in which it is currently to the “new normal risk” phase starting Friday, June 5, calling it a “smart green risk phase.”

    Three indicators

    Beyond two of the commission’s three key indicators — transmission and statewide hospital utilization rates — being outside the commission’s “adequate stability” standard, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention also projects that most of the possible outcomes for Utah in the coming weeks will include accelerating COVID-19 death rates as case counts have spiked in recent days.

    The first indicator, transmission rate, describes the average number of people who contract COVID-19 from a single other person. According to the commission, the figure must be below 1.0 to meet a level of “adequate level of stability.” According to multiple estimates, including those used by the commission, Utah has for weeks been near but just above that 1.0 threshold.

    This graph of COVID-19’s effective reproduction — also known as transmission rate — over time in Utah shows that the state has hovered near but above 1.0 in recent weeks. Staying below 1.0 indicates spread of the disease is likely decreasing. Above 1.0, disease spread is likely increasing. Other estimates show a similar trend to this one. Figure by EpiForecasts and the CMMID Covid working group

    Statewide, the second indicator, the rate of hospital intensive care unit usage, has also been above the commission’s criteria. According to the commission, the average ICU bed usage over the last 14 days has been, on average, 61%, whereas the stability standard is for it to be below 60% over that same period.

    The one indicator that does meet the commission’s standard, community spread, shows that spread of the coronavirus from known contacts has been at 81% for the past two weeks, according to the commission. This is well above the 60% standard the commission set in mid-May and close to the “ideal” level the commission set of 85%.

    Other key figures

    The number of new COVID-19 cases reported each day in Utah has increased over the past 14 days while, in many other states including neighboring Colorado and Nevada, case rates have either stagnated or decreased during the same period. Others, including Idaho and Arizona, have seen increases.

    This number of new daily cases would likely increase over the coming weeks, according to the commission, if the governor enacts the change. The group said the number “has proven to be a poor indicator of health risk for all Utahns,” and thus has not used it as a reopening criterion, but health officials disagree.

    In Moab and elsewhere, experts have used new daily cases as a leading indicator — a canary in the coalmine of sorts — of the pandemic’s localized severity and the number of hospitalizations and deaths that could come. Dunn is among those putting stock in the case numbers.

    Notes: Positive coronavirus test results undercount the actual number of COVID-19 infections. Increases in positive test results may reflect changes in testing availability. Local data leads state data and state data leads national data by a few hours each due to reporting delays.
    Sources: Grand County data comes from the Southeast Utah Health Department. San Juan County data comes from the San Juan County Health Department. Utah data comes from the Utah Department of Health. U.S. data comes from The New York Times. Compiled and plotted by Carter Pape

    “Hospitalization is a lagging metric, so typically somebody has been ill with COVID-19 about a week to 10 days before they are hospitalized, and we have consistently maintained about an 8% hospitalization rate, so we can expect that this increase in cases will result in an increase of hospitalizations in about a week,” Dunn said. “so it’s really important for us to see the leading metric in cases and take action accordingly to avoid overwhelming our hospitals.”

    Local health officials, including those with the Southeast Utah Health Department, are also paying attention to case rates alongside other indicators.

    “New cases are a part of the picture,” said Bradon Bradford, a health officer with the Southeast Utah Health Department. “They shouldn’t be ignored but also should not drive the entire decision about increasing or decreasing social restrictions.”

    Local differences still being promised

    According to the commission, local differences would be allowed across the state if Herbert accepts the recommendation. Herbert also made such a commitment earlier in the pandemic but has since overridden requests from Grand County to impose heavier restrictions on lodgings and other businesses.

    “Specific areas across the state will continue to have the flexibility to easily stay or transition back to higher-risk health guidelines based on real-time data,” the commission said in a collective statement sent by Aundrea Peterson, the Utah Senate’s director of communications.

    Share this!

    - Advertisement -

    Latest News

    GOP’s Cox, Reyes move on to General Election

    If the figures hold, Cox will face off against University of Utah law professor Christopher Peterson, a Democrat, and Libertarian Daniel Cottam, a surgeon, in November’s general election.

    Man pleads guilty to double manslaughter

    He faces up to 15 years apiece for the deaths of Vilsar Camey, 45, and Camey’s 10-year-old son, Israel on Feb. 9.

    Eklecticafe was cramped but quaint. Then the virus hit

    “It’s so sad to say that, even though there’s a relief for me, but the COVID thing… I just couldn’t sustainably reopen."

    500K facemasks headed to Utah students, teachers

    The state procured the masks from H.M. Cole and Totopazi and will be distributed to school districts in the “greatest need."

    After three years and a tripled budget, Seekhaven has new director

    My main goal is to stabilize our current programming and fortify our working relationships with the first responders in our community.